"Asian Americans" + "Occult Racism" - Struggles, Successes, + Legibility

I still find it unbelievable that the documentary only had five hours to tell the entire story of Asian American history. Nonetheless, I think "Asian Americans" was pretty well done; I appreciate how the stories are told by Asian Americans themselves. I like how they give us a glimpse into the lives of various Asian American families and how they jump back and forth between the families to make it all feel somewhat complex, for the history of Asian Americans itself is incredibly complex. 

The documentary definitely has a spirit of perseverance and activism. It primarily focuses on the struggles Asian Americans have faced, but there are moments in which it shows how Asian Americans were able to not only overcome these struggles, but also fight for a better world. For instance, it tells the story of Wong Kim Ark, a Chinese American who helped to define American citizenship after he was denied reentry into the United States. Also, at the end of episode 2, Satsuki Ina says something along the lines of, "No one stood up for us during the incarceration. We will not let this happen today. If we don't participate in the present moment, the past will be recreated." She and Wong Kim Ark are both presented as heroic figures and changemakers. I like that the documentary shows the many painful experiences Asian Americans have gone through; I feel like showing these experiences allows us to appreciate Asian Americans' accomplishments even more. With that being said, the documentary could have included a few examples of Asian American successes, particularly in the arts and in technology. I think it's okay to do this, so long as they acknowledge the struggles too. 

The reading for this week, Schein and Thaj's "Occult Racism: The Masking of Race in the Hmong Hunter Incident," is about the stories that cannot be told in the mainstream. There is so much to think about with the reading, but a question we talked about in class that I am particularly interested in is how the Hmong culture can become legible to our culture when their culture is so different from our own. I really don't know the answer to this question. The way the reading tries to make the Hmong culture legible is via racial antagonism, but I find this very problematic-- the Hmong people should not be defined by their relationship to white people. They are so much more than their relationships with other groups.

It's also interesting to think about when race is masked and when it is not; the article discusses how for the Vang case, "the media highlighted race without discussing the role race played in the incident. It was technically irrelevant, but reported in a way that implied that [Vang's] ethnicity was a cause for him to shoot and kill" (438). Yet for this same case, "territory and property became a really big issue" (438) and when Vang suggested that his actions were triggered by hunters who had made "racially insensitive comments," (438) race was masked and the focus shifted onto the property/trespassing issue. There was simply no winning for Vang, or for the Hmong people. 

Comments

  1. I agree with your assertion that there could have been more of a balance between portraying the successes and struggles of Asian Americans in the documentary. In my view, focusing on the struggle relegates Asian Americans to just a part of the white American story. However, racism still exists and is a very real part of our country's history and it should not be glossed over.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree that legibility through racial antagonism is very problematic. The focus is more on the relation to white people rather than the group being antagonized. I am not quite sure how to promote legibility, but I do think it's important for others to educate themselves on the history and hardships that Asian Americans face in order to begin recognizing things such as micro aggressions.

    I also liked how you mentioned including both struggles and successes of Asian Americans would be more significant for the film. I think it's important to highlight both spectrums rather than only addressing one or the other.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I also found it really ironic that the reading focuses so much on how Asianness as a collective identity hides ethnic variety and specificity, where the Hmong experience an invisibility in the scheme of America centering Chinese and Japanese identity narratives paired with emergent criminality narrative pinned to Asian refugees, but Thoj's film decides to combat that invisibility with extreme violence and conflict. As much as I admired how Thoj constructed the visuals of the film with traditional Hmong storytelling in mind to fully a connection between visual storytelling and Hmong oral-storytelling, it does seem reductive on level to mend political issues while depicting the dead bodies of marginalized Hmong people.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree, five hours is simply not enough for the title of the film. I think the film did well with keeping the tone positive and displayed activism energy. However, the lack of inclusion for all Asian Americans not shown or spoken about goes a long way.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

K-pop: Visual Appeal, Cute Globalization, and Success

PEN15 - Yuki, Ojichan, + the "Racial Middle"

Bling Empire: Struggles, Relatability, + the Reality TV Format